The Aptitude & Attitude Matrix (AAM): A guide to recruiting, identifying, and creating a great startup team

When you’re building a startup, one of the most critical decisions you’ll face is assembling the right team. The team members you choose will shape your company’s culture, drive innovation, and ultimately determine whether your startup succeeds or fails. As a founder, it’s essential to identify and recruit individuals who not only have the skills required but also the attitude and willingness to grow, collaborate, and push your company forward.

In this article, we will explore the different types of team members you are likely to encounter using a 9-block Aptitude & Attitude Matrix (AAM) that evaluates individuals based on two key traits: aptitude (skills and capability) and attitude (willingness and motivation). Understanding the importance of these traits and how to balance them can help you build a team that drives innovation, creates a positive culture, and adapts to challenges quickly.

Superstars (High Aptitude, High Attitude)

Superstars are the ultimate team players, combining exceptional technical skills with a dynamic, forward-thinking attitude. They bring vision, leadership, and an unwavering drive to the table. Not only do they possess the ability to perform at the highest level, but they are also deeply passionate about transforming teams and inspiring others to perform at their best. Superstars are the individuals you’ll rely on for leading strategic initiatives, guiding the team through tough challenges, and fostering a culture of growth and innovation.

These team members are invaluable to your startup, as they bring both technical expertise and the leadership qualities required to take your business to the next level. They are the ones who can rally the team, innovate in critical moments, and adapt quickly to changing environments. Their energy and drive are contagious, and they set the tone for the entire organization. If you can find and nurture Superstars, they will likely become the cornerstone of your company’s success.

Traits:

• Dynamic Leaders: They combine exceptional skills with an inspiring drive.
• Transformative Impact: Superstars have the ability to drive teams toward success and growth.
• Team Motivators: They have high energy and foster a collaborative and innovative environment.

Roadmap:

• Provide them with autonomy and trust, allowing them to lead critical projects and initiatives.
• Offer them opportunities for growth and leadership roles.
• Encourage their ideas and make them feel valued by involving them in high-level decision-making.

Superstars are the cornerstone of your startup. They not only deliver excellent results but also shape the culture and direction of your company. By fostering their leadership and giving them the space to innovate, you’ll maximize their potential and keep them motivated.

---

Specialists (High Aptitude, Mid Attitude)

Specialists are highly skilled individuals who excel in specific areas but may not necessarily show the same drive or initiative to innovate on their own. These team members are highly reliable when given clear direction and can deliver exceptional quality in their specialized roles. While they are less likely to take the lead in driving change or challenging the status quo, they are indispensable when it comes to technical expertise or operational efficiency.

Specialists are perfect for filling roles that require deep, specific knowledge or expertise. While they may not be the most innovative members of your team, their ability to execute well-defined tasks with high accuracy and efficiency is valuable. Their skills will support your startup’s foundation, and with the right encouragement, they can evolve to take on more creative or leadership roles as the company grows.

Traits:

• Reliable Experts: They excel in specific technical areas and deliver high-quality work when directed.
• Less Initiative: They may lack the drive to innovate without guidance.
• Focused Performers: They thrive when given clear instructions and are highly dependable.

Roadmap:

• Set clear goals and provide them with a structured framework for success.
• Empower them to take on projects where their expertise can shine, but encourage creativity within their domain.
• Recognize their skills and give them a chance to take ownership of specific tasks while providing support to encourage new ideas.

Specialists are essential for ensuring the quality and execution of critical tasks. However, they require guidance and structure to maximize their potential. Offering them growth opportunities while respecting their expertise will help them become more engaged and valuable.

---

Technicians (High Aptitude, Low Attitude)

Technicians are individuals who possess high levels of technical skill but lack the enthusiasm or engagement to contribute meaningfully to team culture or innovation. While they can perform their job effectively and with proficiency, their lack of enthusiasm or willingness to collaborate can create challenges in a startup environment. Technicians tend to work best in roles that allow them to operate independently, but their isolation can sometimes hinder collaboration and broader organizational growth.

While their technical aptitude is unquestionable, the lack of drive and willingness to engage with others can limit their overall impact on your startup. If you recruit a Technician, it’s important to ensure they are in a role that requires minimal interaction and is highly task-focused. You may also need to invest in strategies to encourage them to become more involved with the team and motivate them to push beyond their basic responsibilities.

Traits:

• Highly Skilled: Technicians are proficient in their tasks but lack enthusiasm or engagement.
• Low Enthusiasm: They may not actively participate in team activities or contribute to innovation.
• Independent Workers: They excel in independent tasks but struggle in collaborative environments.

Roadmap:

• Assign them roles where they can work independently and leverage their technical skills.
• Ensure they are aware of how their work impacts the larger team and encourage them to engage more with colleagues.
• Regularly check in to offer support, but be mindful of not micromanaging.

Technicians can be a great asset to your team in roles where independence and specialized skills are required. However, their disengagement can hinder overall collaboration. It’s important to provide them with clear responsibilities and encourage them to participate in team activities for holistic growth.

---

Rising Stars (Mid Aptitude, High Attitude)

Rising Stars are individuals with high potential who bring a positive attitude and an eagerness to learn and grow, but they may not yet possess all the technical skills required for a given role. These individuals are highly adaptable, willing to take on new challenges, and motivated to improve their skills. Their drive to succeed often compensates for their initial lack of expertise. Rising Stars are ideal for roles that require growth potential and for individuals who need some training and mentorship to fully realize their capabilities.

Rising Stars are a great investment for your startup, as they will grow alongside your company. They may start in entry-level positions, but with the right guidance and opportunities for growth, they can evolve into leaders who take ownership of critical functions. Look for candidates who show initiative, a desire for self-improvement, and an ability to work hard to develop the skills they currently lack.

Traits:

• Eager Learners: Rising Stars are highly motivated and ready to develop their skills.
• Adaptable: They are flexible and open to feedback, making them quick to adapt to new situations.
• Growth-Oriented: They may not have all the technical skills yet, but they bring a lot of enthusiasm and potential.

Roadmap:

• Provide mentorship and training to help them grow their skill set.
• Give them responsibility early on to help them learn and improve quickly.
• Offer regular feedback and encourage them to take on challenges, even if they don’t have all the answers.

Rising Stars are the future of your team. With the right support, they can grow into high-value team members. Invest time in their development, and you will see rapid improvement and increased loyalty to the company.

---

Steady Contributors (Mid Aptitude, Mid Attitude)

Steady Contributors are reliable team members who may not stand out for their creativity or leadership but consistently perform their work well. They offer stability and consistency, getting the job done without major fluctuations in attitude or performance. They are dependable and keep things running smoothly, but they don’t tend to take initiative or push beyond the basic expectations.

These team members are excellent for maintaining daily operations, managing routine tasks, and ensuring that the business runs without any disruptions. However, if you want to build a team that thrives in a fast-moving startup environment, you’ll need to ensure that Steady Contributors have the support and motivation needed to step up and engage with more dynamic responsibilities. They are important for stability but will need extra encouragement to take on new challenges or contribute to innovation.

Traits:

• Consistent and Reliable: They are dependable and consistently deliver solid work.
• Low Initiative: They don’t typically push beyond their responsibilities or seek innovation.
• Balanced Performance: They perform well without fluctuations but may not drive growth.

Roadmap:

• Provide a stable environment where they can thrive on routine tasks and responsibilities.
• Recognize their dependability and give them opportunities to gradually take on more responsibility.
• Encourage small steps toward innovation and creative thinking, ensuring they feel supported.

Steady Contributors provide stability and are great for ensuring day-to-day operations run smoothly. While they may not be the ones to lead change, their consistency helps maintain the foundation of your startup. With encouragement, they can grow to take on more dynamic roles.

---

Stagnators (Mid Aptitude, Low Attitude)

Stagnators are individuals who possess the necessary skills to perform their tasks adequately but lack the enthusiasm and drive to push beyond the basics. They often show resistance to change and are not proactive in seeking opportunities for improvement or innovation. While they can complete their work to a satisfactory level, they are more comfortable with maintaining the status quo and tend to avoid taking on new challenges. This complacency can be a hindrance in a startup environment, where constant growth, adaptability, and creative problem-solving are essential for success. Without the drive to push themselves, Stagnators can become a bottleneck in the progress of the team and the company.

To handle Stagnators effectively, it is important to provide them with clear and structured tasks, as they perform best when given specific directions and expectations. Encouraging them to take on new challenges and explaining the benefits of embracing change can help nudge them toward growth. Regular feedback is crucial, especially to address any complacency and to emphasize areas where improvement is needed. While Stagnators may not naturally seek innovation, with the right guidance and a focus on how their contributions align with the startup’s overall success, they can be motivated to engage more actively. However, if they remain resistant to change and development, they could limit the team’s ability to evolve and adapt, requiring further intervention or, in some cases, reconsideration of their fit within the team.

Traits:

• Adequate Skills: They have the necessary technical capabilities but lack the drive to push beyond the basics.
• Resistance to Change: Stagnators are often resistant to new ideas, feedback, or growth opportunities.
• Complacency: They tend to maintain the status quo and are not eager to go the extra mile.

Roadmap:

• Provide Clear Direction: Stagnators need clear instructions and guidelines to perform effectively. Offering them structured tasks will help them succeed without requiring too much creative input.
• Encourage Change: Gently push them to take on new challenges and emphasize the importance of continuous improvement. Make them understand how adapting to change benefits the team and the company’s growth.
• Provide Regular Feedback: Offer consistent, constructive feedback and focus on making them aware of areas where improvement is necessary. Help them see the bigger picture and how their role fits into the broader success of the company.

Stagnators can be a challenge in a fast-paced startup environment where flexibility and constant growth are required. They can still contribute effectively to tasks that are routine and require little innovation. However, you’ll need to encourage them to embrace change and get out of their comfort zone for greater long-term impact.

---

Strugglers (Mid Aptitude, Low Attitude)

Strugglers are individuals who may have some aptitude but face difficulties in performing their job effectively. They may need significant guidance and direction to improve their skills and often show a moderate willingness to try. However, their lack of motivation or commitment to self-improvement can hold them back. Strugglers may require extensive mentorship and support to become productive members of the team.

While Strugglers have some potential, they often require constant supervision and external motivation to grow. In a startup, where speed and adaptability are key, these individuals can become a bottleneck if not properly supported. It’s important to consider whether you have the time and resources to help them develop their skills. If not, they may not be the right fit for your team at this stage.

Traits:

• Adequate Skills: They may have some capability but struggle with execution or adapting to new challenges.
• Needs Guidance: They require significant direction and feedback to perform effectively.
• Moderate Willingness: They are somewhat motivated but not consistently resilient in overcoming challenges.

Roadmap:

• Provide regular, hands-on mentorship and structured learning plans.
• Break down tasks into manageable steps to help them succeed.
• Offer plenty of feedback and be patient, ensuring they know they’re supported as they grow.

Strugglers have the potential to improve with the right training and support. With your guidance, they can grow, but it will require extra effort from you and the team. If they show progress, they can eventually contribute more effectively.

---

Underdogs (Low Aptitude, High Attitude)

Underdogs are eager learners who, while lacking some key technical skills, are driven to improve and grow. Their positive attitude and willingness to learn make them valuable team members, even if they don’t have all the experience required. Underdogs are often the most motivated individuals, pushing themselves to succeed despite starting with fewer resources or knowledge. With the right support, they can develop into key players within the organization.

Underdogs are great candidates for entry-level or developmental roles where they can grow their skills and contribute positively to the team. They may not have the expertise initially, but their enthusiasm and determination will help them succeed in the long run. If you invest in their development, they can become high performers who add great value to the startup.

Traits:

• Eager to Learn: They have a great attitude and are willing to do whatever it takes to improve.
• Positive and Resilient: Despite lacking some key skills, they are persistent and show remarkable determination.
• High Growth Potential: They bring enthusiasm and are hungry for self-improvement.

Roadmap:

• Provide a clear path for development, including mentorship and educational resources.
• Assign them progressively challenging tasks that push their boundaries while still allowing room for learning.
• Regularly celebrate their small wins to keep them motivated and reinforce their sense of growth.

Underdogs may start with fewer skills, but their willingness to learn makes them highly adaptable. If you invest in their development, they can become invaluable assets to the team. Provide them with growth opportunities and watch them exceed expectations.

---

Underachievers (Low Aptitude, Low Attitude)

Underachievers are the most difficult team members to manage. They are unmotivated and underperforming, which can negatively impact both team morale and overall productivity. They often show little interest in improving their skills or engaging with the team, which can create a toxic work environment and undermine the startup’s culture. Underachievers may cause disruption, and unless they are willing to make significant changes, they should be avoided in a startup setting.

Recruiting Underachievers can be detrimental to your team’s success. Their lack of both aptitude and attitude can drain resources and energy from the team, making it difficult for your startup to maintain momentum. If you identify an Underachiever on your team, consider whether it’s worth the time and effort to try and change their behavior. In most cases, they may need to be let go to preserve the company’s culture and avoid further disruption.

Traits:

• Unmotivated: They show little interest in improving or engaging with the team.
• Underperformers: They struggle to meet basic expectations and often require significant intervention.
• Team Drainers: Their low enthusiasm can negatively impact team morale and culture.

Roadmap:

• Assess whether they are a fit for the startup environment; they may not thrive in a fast-paced, growth-driven setting.
• If you choose to invest in them, set clear expectations, offer constant feedback, and ensure they are held accountable.
• In most cases, if Underachievers do not improve over time, it may be necessary to part ways to preserve the team culture.

Underachievers can create a toxic environment if left unchecked. Their lack of engagement and drive can demoralize others, so it’s essential to address their behavior early on. In some cases, it may be best to part ways with these individuals to protect the team and the company culture.

---

Final Thoughts: Building a winning team

Building the right founding team is one of the most important aspects of building a successful startup. While skills and expertise are important, attitude—the willingness to learn, adapt, and collaborate—is often the more critical factor in determining long-term success. As you recruit, identify, and nurture your team, keep these distinctions in mind and focus on balancing aptitude with the right attitude.

A strong founding team should consist of a mix of Superstars, Rising Stars, Specialists, and Underdogs, all of whom are motivated and aligned with the startup’s vision. By carefully evaluating candidates based on their skills and attitude, you can create a dynamic, innovative, and resilient team capable of adapting to the challenges and opportunities that come with scaling a startup. Your team will be your greatest asset—invest wisely, and watch your startup thrive.